Weekly Homily from Fr Jim Hogan, 4th Sunday in Lent, March 15, 2015

•2 Chronicles 36:14-16, 19-23 • Ephesians 2:4-10 • John 3:14-21•

Scripture Readings: Fourth Sunday in Lent

Gradually Francis of Rome is restoring the possibility of openness and honest discussion within our Catholic household of faith. I consider his actions and words genuine reflections of the life and teaching of the historical Jesus. I see him as a man of love whose personal trust in the Spirit is so evident. Some call this the “Francis effect.”

However not all of our peers are motivated by Francis.  In college a young woman walked out the door, determined never to return.  Touched by the “Francis effect” she decided to return.  After several weeks she sought the Sacrament of Reconciliation.  It was a disaster.  The confessor yelled at her and scolded her.  So much for the Francis effect!

I speak of her experience because there is a lesson for us in that confessor’s deplorable behavior.  Scripture texts are a primary vehicle through which the Christ Mystery is communicated to us.  I suspect that for most of us our only exposure to scripture is our liturgical lectionary.   Our current lectionary often removes and isolates scripture passages from their larger context.  So I caution you.  Always remember there is a larger context without which such texts are easily misread and misinterpreted.

We see this today in the passage from the gospel of John. This text can be correctly understood  only if we remember it is the conclusion of a discussion between Jesus and “a leader of the Jews, a Pharisee named Nicodemus.”  The words attributed to Jesus, “whoever does not believe stands condemned” are strong words.  If removed and isolated from the larger context the text is easily misread or misinterpreted.  A confessor who yells at and scolds someone as “condemned” has apparently read this text out of context.

Many scholars agree that the gospel of John was written in different layers by different authors over a period of about thirty years.  Each layer reflects distinct episodes in early Christian history. In the initial layer, Jesus is seen as the promised Jewish messiah. The second layer reflects the rising hostility between the followers of Jesus and the leaders of the synagogue.  The final layer reflects the struggle of those early Christians to live apart from Judaism.

Our task always is to search through those layers of the written gospels for the “good news.”  That means pondering each text within its larger context, which for this passage is Jesus teaching Nicodemus that God’s mercy extends beyond Israel.  “Whoever does not believe stands condemned” is a forceful statement.  If read out of context, it is not “good news!”

John’s Jesus was telling Nicodemus, “God loved the world” as it is and people as they are.  He is saying God infuses and envelops the world and all people with love. That includes you and me and all of our perceived enemies, with no condition or pre-requisite!

His teaching continues.  God’s purpose is “not to condemn the world, but to save the world.” The phrase “to save the world”  is ambiguous, raising the question–  from what?  Not from “sin” since the text does not mention “sin.”  Within the larger context it becomes clear that “to save” means drawing, pulling, assimilating us into more and more life — “eternal life!”   That is good news!

We live in an evolutionary world and each of us are incomplete works in progress; capable of the best and the worst; struggling with internal and external conflicts and contradictions; threatened and confused by terrorism, epidemics and destructive storms.  We all need and hunger for “good news.”  The “Good News!” is this.  That Gracious Mystery we name God loves us, breathes life into us, pulls and draws us into ever fuller and more complete life.

Now carry this one step further.  As Lent moves us into Easter, remember that we ordinary men and women are “The Living Body of Christ.”  Christ lives in us, acts through us, loves through us.  Nothing can, nothing should stop us from bringing a little love into the world.  Day after day our words and actions, like those of Francis of Rome, are changing the world with love.


This entry was posted in Hogan's Homilies. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Weekly Homily from Fr Jim Hogan, 4th Sunday in Lent, March 15, 2015

  1. Ted Seeber says:

    If breaking the seal of the confessional is the Francis Experience, I for one want nothing to do with it. I am a 44 year old heterosexual monogamous married Catholic, and the level of Judgement I have received for my lifestyle since Francis became Pope has been astonishing.

    • Reyanna Rice says:

      I am sorry that you have suffered such judgment and treatment. I would have to say that what you have experienced, based on my own experiences, is not the norm for those who follow Pope Fancis. I suspect what you are calling breaking the seal of the confessional is not quite what happened. The writer of this article would in no way do that. I know him well and when I asked him about this, he stated he had read the story of the young woman. It could be that the young woman willingly shared here experience with this confessor. From all that I have read of Pope Francis in what he says to priests about confession, this confessor was way out of line. If I could make contact with the person, I would encourage her to write to Pope Francis. I would encourage you to do the same.

  2. Bonnie Owens says:

    In response to your homily, I share this. Mention the name Francis and most people of any religion or no religion know who I mean. And many Christians, not only Catholics, have heard and can quote things Francis has said. The “Francis effect” is, to me, a breath of fresh air, has given me renewed hope for our church and resulted in one of the best faith sharing experiences I’ve ever had studying the Joy of the Gospel. For 14 years I was a parishioner in a parish in Portland Oregon you visited a few years ago. You heard our pain and anguish about our angry parish priest who has succeeded in driving away three fourths of the parishioners through his actions. I wonder, had not Francis been elected pope, would I still be a member of the Catholic Church today? I am 75 years old, a lifelong Catholic. I have lived in ten states, have been a member of 15 parishes yet I have never encountered a parish priest so able to alienate people. I read Francis and have chosen a different worship community, at least until another priest is assigned to that parish, to sustain me. It has been a time of grieving because I had found such a good community of friends, good liturgy and a niche in which I could volunteer. It’s been destroyed. To all of this God must have some valid purpose but I do not know what. I have never learned anything in 16 years of Catholic education and all of the subsequent retreats, workshops, conferences and homilies that says it is okay for an angry priest to do this. And by the way, the “Francis effect” has no apparent effect on this priest. He does not care for Pope Francis.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *